Mitigating Factors: How Circumstances Affect Sexual Assault Defence

March 1, 2024


Sexual assault is a serious crime that carries severe penalties and lasting consequences for both the accused. However, not every case of sexual assault is clear-cut or straightforward. Mitigating factors may affect how the defence lawyer presents the case and how the court decides the outcome.

In this blog post, we will explore some of the common circumstances that can influence sexual assault defence in Alberta and how a skilled and experienced sexual assault defence lawyer can help you navigate the complex legal process.

Legal Landscape: Navigating Evolving Standards

Sexual assault is a criminal offence which defines it as any form of sexual contact without consent. However, the legal definition of consent has changed over time as the courts and society have recognized the nuances and complexities of sexual interactions. In the ever-shifting legal landscape surrounding sexual assault cases, staying abreast of the latest standards is imperative.

A seasoned sexual assault defence lawyer is a legal guide navigating through these dynamic terrains, where societal norms, expectations, and legislative changes are in constant flux. As laws adapt to a more nuanced understanding of consent, a proficient attorney not only interprets these changes but strategically utilizes them to construct a robust defence.

Context Matters: Impact Of Circumstances On Defence

Not every case of sexual assault is the same. Different circumstances may affect how the defence lawyer approaches the case and how the court evaluates the evidence. For instance, some of the factors that may influence the defence strategy are:

  • The relationship between the accused and the complainant: Was it a one-time encounter, a casual or long-term relationship, a professional or familial connection, or a situation of power imbalance or coercion?
  • The nature of the sexual act: Was it consensual at first and then became non-consensual, or was it non-consensual from the start? Was it violent or non-violent, or did it involve any weapons or injuries?
  • The timing and location of the incident: When and where did it happen, and how long did it last? Was it in a public or private place or a secluded or crowded area? Was it during the day or night or under the influence of alcohol or drugs?
  • The behaviour and communication of the parties: How did they express their consent or lack thereof, verbally or non-verbally? How did they react during and after the incident, emotionally or physically? Did they report the incident immediately or after a delay, and to whom?

These and other circumstances may have a significant impact on the defence of a sexual assault case, as they may affect the perception and interpretation of the facts by the judge or jury.

Also Read: How Sexual Assault Lawyers Challenge Molestation Evidence In Court

Role Of Intent: Unraveling Complexities In Sexual Assault Cases

One of the critical elements of a sexual assault offence is the intent of the accused. The prosecution must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the accused intended to touch the complainant sexually without their consent. However, proving intent is not always easy, as it involves delving into the subjective state of mind of the accused at the time of the incident.

Moreover, there may be situations where the accused may have a mistaken belief or a lack of knowledge that may affect their intent. For example, the accused may claim that they honestly believed that the complainant consented to the sexual act based on their words or actions.

This is known as the defence of honest but mistaken belief in consent, which may be raised in some cases of sexual assault.

Expert Strategies: The Craft Of A Sexual Assault Defence Lawyer

Defending a sexual assault case is not an easy task. It requires a high level of skill, experience, and professionalism from the sexual assault defence lawyer. The lawyer must be able to:

  • Conduct a thorough investigation and analysis of the case and gather all the relevant evidence and information, such as medical records, witness statements, forensic reports, and digital data.
  • Develop a strong and coherent defence strategy and identify the best possible arguments and defences for their client, such as consent, alibi, mistaken identity, or reasonable doubt.
  • Cross-examine the prosecution witnesses and challenge their credibility and reliability while avoiding improper or unfair questioning that may violate the complainant’s or the accused’s rights.
  • Represent the interests and rights of their client and protect them from any prejudice or discrimination while maintaining the highest standards of ethics and professionalism.

About Daryl Royer

Daryl Royer, a seasoned criminal defence lawyer in Edmonton, Alberta, holds a law degree from the University of Saskatchewan College of Law (2001). With over two decades of dedicated practice in criminal defence law, Mr. Royer has handled a wide spectrum of cases—from murder, sexual assault, impaired driving, fraud, and theft to various other offences—across multiple judicial levels.

If you require the expertise of an experienced sexual assault defence lawyer in Edmonton, don’t hesitate to contact Daryl for effective legal representation.

Get A Free Consultation, Contact Daryl Royer Today

Get A Free Consultation Contact Us